MemberDay vs Join It
The Join It alternative with zero transaction fees
Join It is a clean, modern membership tool with a matching $29 entry price. The difference is what happens when your club collects money: Join It takes 1.5–3% of every transaction on top of card fees, has no native mobile app, and leans on integrations for events, email, and websites. MemberDay includes those pieces — and takes $0 of your payments.
MemberDay is the better fit for…
- Clubs that collect dues and event payments and want to keep 100%
- Clubs that want events, email, committees, files, and tasks built in — not via integrations
- Members who expect a real mobile app
- Clubs that want a platform partner focused on clubs specifically
Join It may be the better fit for…
- Simple membership-card use cases (gyms, museums, alumni lists)
- Organizations that live in Zapier/Mailchimp and want a thin membership layer
- Groups that don’t collect much money through the platform
We'd rather you pick the right tool than the loudest pitch — this comparison names real strengths on both sides.
Monthly price by club size
Published pricing as of July 2026 — competitor pricing and features may change, so confirm details with each provider. MemberDay is flat at every size — Join It's price changes as you grow.
| Members | MemberDay Core | Join It |
|---|---|---|
| 25 | $29/mo | ~$29/mo |
| 50 | $29/mo | ~$29/mo |
| 100 | $29/mo | ~$29/mo |
| 250 | $29/mo | ~$29/mo |
| 500 | $29/mo | ~$39/mo |
Year-one, all-in — 60-member club processing $10,000/yr online
MemberDay
$319 (Core, annual — $0 setup, $0 payment markup)
Join It
~$613 ($313 Starter annual + ~$300 in 3% transaction fees on $10k)
Excludes the ~2.9% + 30¢ base card fee every platform's customers pay. Run your own numbers →
Side by side
| MemberDay | Join It | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Flat — unlimited members | Feature tiers + member-count slider |
| Transaction fees | 0% markup — your own Stripe account | 1.5–3% of every payment (can be passed to members) |
| Setup fee | $0 | $0 |
| Mobile app | Native iOS & Android apps included | No native member app |
| Events & registration | Built in, with volunteer management | Basic; leans on integrations (e.g. Eventbrite) |
| Email & communication | Built in with open tracking | Mailchimp integration |
| AI features | Built-in assistant + AI survey import | None |
| Digital membership cards | Digital membership card with QR code in the app | Yes — polished digital cards |
| Third-party integrations | Focused, built-in feature set | Broad (Zapier, Mailchimp, Eventbrite...) |
Sources: Join It's published pricing and documentation, checked July 2026. Spot something outdated? Let us know.
Switching from Join It is our job, not yours
Export your data from Join It, send it to us, and our team imports your member roster free — typically within a week. Then use the rest of your 45-day trial to run real club work before your board decides.
How Free Migration WorksThe switch, step by step
- Start your free trial (no credit card)
- Export your data from Join It and email it to us
- We import your members, contacts, and member types — free
- Review together, invite your officers, go live
FAQ
MemberDay vs Join It
Join It is also $29/month — what’s the real difference?
The transaction fee. Join It adds 1.5–3% to every payment your club collects (on top of normal card fees). A club processing $10,000 a year hands over $150–$300 annually — often more than the subscription itself. MemberDay adds 0%: you connect your own Stripe account and keep everything.
Does Join It have a mobile app?
Join It has no native member mobile app — members use the mobile web. MemberDay includes real iOS and Android apps for every member at no extra cost.
What does Join It do better?
It’s a genuinely clean product with polished digital membership cards and a wide integration catalog. If you mostly need a membership database that talks to other tools, it’s reasonable — our case is the all-in-one club feature set and zero payment markup.
Can you migrate our Join It data?
Yes — export your members from Join It and our team will import your roster free, usually within a week.
More comparisons
Try the Join It alternative free
Full platform, your real data (we migrate it free), 45 days, no credit card. Bring the results to your next board meeting.